Skip to content
Proxus 2.0.0 Proxus 2.0: the largest release in Proxus history Release notes

Comparison · A DIY stack

You can build this. The question is who maintains it in year three.

Telegraf, InfluxDB and Grafana (with a few scripts and maybe Node-RED) will collect industrial data and chart it, for the price of the hardware. Plenty of good plants run exactly this. It is a real option and we will not pretend otherwise; the honest comparison is about what happens after it works.

What it is
A DIY stack: Open-source assembly, typically Telegraf, InfluxDB, Grafana and scripts
What Proxus is
An industrial data platform: collect, model, govern, store, deliver
Honest summary
Cheap to start, genuinely capable, and the maintenance is the product you end up owning.
Your options
Usually one or the other: keep building, or move collection, modelling and history into Proxus and keep the parts that earn their keep, such as Grafana. Both paths are below.

Give them their due

What A DIY stack is genuinely good at.

A comparison that only lists the other product's weaknesses is a sales sheet, not a decision aid. These are real strengths, and some of them are reasons not to buy Proxus.

  • Excellent components, freely available

    Telegraf ships as a standalone binary with hundreds of plugins including MQTT, Modbus and OPC UA, and buffers at the edge. InfluxDB and Grafana are mature. None of this is a compromise.

  • No licence conversation

    You can start this afternoon without procurement, and prove value before anyone asks for a budget line.

  • Complete control

    Every part is inspectable and replaceable. For teams with the skills and the appetite, that is worth more than any vendor relationship.

  • Skills that transfer

    What your team learns building it applies far beyond this project, which is not true of most vendor-specific tooling.

Attribute by attribute

Where the two actually differ.

Both columns are filled in. Where A DIY stack is ahead, the row says so.

  • Time to first chart

    Proxus

    Comparable for the first device, and the modelling work is what takes the extra time.

    A DIY stack

    Fast. An afternoon for a familiar protocol.

  • Industrial protocols

    Proxus

    66 protocols across 30 vendor and standard families natively, including CNC and robot controllers.

    In the docs: Industrial protocols

    A DIY stack

    Modbus, OPC UA, MQTT and Siemens S7 are covered. Most other vendor PLC, CNC and robot protocols are not, and that is where the custom work starts.

  • Data model

    Proxus

    A modelled namespace with units, quality and asset context, with changes recorded in the audit trail.

    In the docs: Data model

    A DIY stack

    Measurement and tag names agreed by convention. The model lives in dashboards, queries and people.

  • Access control

    Proxus

    One role model across data, screens, APIs and AI clients, including namespace paths.

    In the docs: Access control

    A DIY stack

    Per component: database users, Grafana roles, host access. Coherent per-signal permissions are hard to assemble.

  • Configuration management

    Proxus

    Pipelines keep revisions you can compare; every other configuration change is recorded in the audit trail.

    In the docs: Configuration management

    A DIY stack

    Config files and dashboards in version control if the team is disciplined about it.

  • Where configuration lives

    Proxus

    Centrally on the hub. A replacement gateway is installed with a new command from the hub and pulls the same devices, rules and functions.

    In the docs: Where configuration lives

    A DIY stack

    Config files on each host, in version control if the team is disciplined about it.

  • Multi-site

    Proxus

    Templates and a gateway fleet with central visibility.

    In the docs: Multi-site

    A DIY stack

    The same stack per site, kept consistent by process. Drift is the normal failure mode.

  • Moving parts at a site

    Proxus

    One gateway process plus a messaging container for the local buffer, installed by one script. The seams between components are inside one codebase rather than between four.

    In the docs: Moving parts at a site

    A DIY stack

    An agent, a database, a dashboard server and usually a broker: four products to version, patch and supervise.

  • Who supports it

    Proxus

    A vendor with release notes, certified processes and a support channel.

    Certificates: Who supports it

    A DIY stack

    Your team, plus community channels. The person who built it is the escalation path.

  • Cost shape

    Proxus

    A licence priced by gateways and data rate, from $5,500 a year as published, with the maintenance inside it.

    Pricing: Cost shape

    A DIY stack

    No licence. Engineering time up front and, more importantly, maintenance for as long as it runs.

Proxus figures come from the current build's own driver and target inventory. A DIY stack figures come from the vendor's published material, linked at the end of this page. Nothing here is measured on a benchmark neither party has agreed to.

Choose A DIY stack

When we are not the answer.

  • One site, a handful of signals, and an engineer who wants to own it: a platform would be overhead.
  • The protocols involved are Modbus, OPC UA or MQTT, which the open components already handle well.
  • The team has genuine capacity for the maintenance, not just the enthusiasm for the build.
  • The data is for engineering curiosity rather than decisions the business will defend in an audit.

Choose Proxus

When the shape of the problem fits.

  • The stack became load-bearing and the person who built it has moved on, or would like to.
  • The equipment includes controllers the open plugins do not speak.
  • A security review needs one access model, not four, and an audit trail behind the numbers.
  • Site two and site three have to look like site one without depending on the same engineer.

Not either/or

How they are used together.

  • Keep Grafana, change what feeds it

    InfluxDB is a supported target. Existing dashboards keep working while the collection and modelling underneath become someone’s product rather than someone’s script.

    InfluxDB integration
  • Telegraf where it is already good

    For infrastructure and IT metrics, Telegraf stays the better tool. Proxus does not need to own everything that produces a number.

  • Keep the scripts that earn their keep

    Genuinely custom logic can move into a C# function inside the pipeline, where it is governed and supported rather than scheduled by cron.

Sources

Last checked against vendor material: October 2026.

Products change. If something on this page is out of date or wrong, tell us and we will fix it, including when the correction favours A DIY stack.

Questions

Proxus and A DIY stack: short answers.

Can we keep our Grafana dashboards?
Yes. InfluxDB is a supported target, so existing dashboards keep working while Proxus takes over collection and modelling underneath.
Which protocols do the open-source components cover?
Modbus, OPC UA, MQTT and Siemens S7. Most other vendor PLC, CNC and robot protocols are not covered; Proxus has native drivers for 66 protocols across 30 vendor and standard families.
What does Proxus cost compared with a free stack?
A licence priced by gateways and data rate, from $5,500 a year as published, with the maintenance inside it. The open-source stack has no licence; its cost is engineering time and maintenance for as long as it runs.

Next step

Compare year three, not day one.

Install Proxus next to what you built, point it at the same controllers and compare the work it takes. An evaluation key gets you started; an engineer answers the questions it raises.

  1. 01

    Scoping call

    Equipment, protocols, sites and the systems the data has to reach.

  2. 02

    Technical walkthrough

    A working demo against a scenario that resembles your plant, not a generic tour.

  3. 03

    Pilot plan

    A defined first line or site, with the deployment and security questions answered up front.

  4. 04

    Roll-out

    The same templates bring the next lines and sites online.